Tennessee Titans' Offensive Line Crisis: Are They NFL's Most Overpaid Unit?

The Tennessee Titans' offensive tackles are the NFL’s most overpaid unit, according to new analysis, as the franchise struggles with a 3-14 record and two-game losing streak heading into their September 13 matchup against the New York Jets. The contracts of players like Jack Conklin and David Bakhtiari are under the microscope after years of inconsistent production.

Why Are Titans’ Tackles the Most Overpaid?

The Titans rank 16th in the AFC, and their offensive line has been a major factor. Conklin, signed for $14 million in 2024, and Bakhtiari, who earned $12 million last season, have failed to meet expectations. The unit allowed 50 sacks in 2025—the second-worst mark in the league—hindering quarterback Will Levis’ development.

How Do Contracts Compare to Performance?

Conklin’s $14 million deal—$10 million guaranteed—makes him one of the highest-paid tackles in the league despite averaging just 28 starts over two seasons. Bakhtiari, who missed 10 games in 2025 due to injury, earned $12 million, including $7 million guaranteed. Neither has shown the durability or consistency to justify those figures.

What’s Next for the Titans’ Offensive Line?

With the Jets looming on September 13, the Titans’ offense will need improvement. If the line doesn’t turn things around, GM Jon Robinson may face pressure to restructure contracts or explore trades. The unit’s struggles could also impact the franchise tag decisions for 2027.

Who’s Most at Risk?

Conklin’s contract expires after 2026, but his production hasn’t matched his pay. Bakhtiari’s injury history raises questions about his long-term value. If the Titans can’t improve their pass protection, both could become cap casualties sooner rather than later.